The Challenge of Proving a Waterproof Membrane in Your Home
As homes in our area are exposed to extreme weather conditions, waterproofing has become an essential defense mechanism. One of the most effective solutions is the installation of a waterproof membrane, a crucial barrier that prevents water infiltration during heavy rains, hurricanes, and other severe weather events. While a waterproof membrane provides substantial protection against water damage, proving its existence—especially for the purpose of securing insurance discounts or selling a property—can be surprisingly difficult.
What Is a Waterproof Membrane?
Despite the significant protection it provides, proving that a waterproof membrane is present—and in good condition—can be a challenge for homeowners, contractors, and even inspectors.
Why Is It So Hard to Prove the Existence of a Waterproof Membrane?
1. Hidden Installation
One of the primary difficulties in proving a waterproof membrane’s presence is its location. By nature, waterproof membranes are hidden under layers of construction materials, such as roofing shingles, tiles, or exterior siding. Once the home is fully constructed, the membrane is no longer visible or accessible without removing part of the roof or wall—an invasive and costly process that most homeowners are unwilling to undertake and inspectors can’t undertake.
For homeowners who did not build the house themselves, they may have little to no knowledge of whether a waterproof membrane exists, particularly if there is no documentation from the original builder.
2. Lack of Documentation
Many homeowners face challenges in providing documentation that verifies the installation of a waterproof membrane, particularly if their home was built many years ago or if the construction company no longer exists. In some cases, a waterproof membrane may have been installed as part of an informal or non-standardized process, making it difficult to obtain written confirmation.
Even when a waterproof membrane is installed in a new home, homeowners may not always receive specific documentation or warranties proving its existence. Builders may provide general construction documents or warranties but leave out details on specialized features like waterproof membranes. Without this paperwork, convincing an insurance company or a potential buyer of the membrane's existence can be problematic.
3. Inspection Limitations
While wind mitigation inspections are a common method for proving the hurricane-resistant features of a home, they are limited in their ability to confirm the presence of a waterproof membrane. Inspectors typically assess visible features such as roof coverings, hurricane clips, window protection, and door reinforcements. However, because waterproof membranes are hidden beneath the surface, inspectors cannot easily verify their existence without destructive testing.
An inspector might offer general insights into the likelihood of a waterproof membrane based on other construction techniques or the age of the home, but this is not sufficient proof for insurance companies, who often demand more concrete evidence.
4. Retrofits and Unverified Upgrades
Homeowners who retrofit their homes with waterproof membranes during a renovation may face an additional challenge: the absence of official building permits or verified records of the work. If the retrofit was performed by a contractor without proper documentation, or if homeowners opted for a DIY approach, the insurance company or future buyers may question the quality and legitimacy of the installation.
Even in cases where the homeowner does have some documentation, proving that the membrane remains intact after years of exposure to weather and wear can be difficult without invasive testing.
Solutions for Proving the Existence of a Waterproof Membrane
Despite these challenges, there are several steps homeowners can take to prove the existence of a waterproof membrane and potentially secure insurance discounts, improve resale value, or provide peace of mind.
1. Request Original Construction Documents
If the waterproof membrane was installed during the construction of the home, the first step is to locate any documentation that proves its existence. Contact the original builder, general contractor, or roofing company to request records. Construction plans, material lists, and product warranties can provide evidence that a waterproof membrane was installed. In some cases, manufacturers may offer warranties for the product, which can serve as proof that the membrane is in place.
For older homes, this process can be more difficult, especially if the builder or contractor is no longer in business. In such cases, reviewing the home's original building permits may reveal some details about the construction methods used.
2. Consult a Roofing or Waterproofing Specialist
If you're unsure whether your home has a waterproof membrane or if you need confirmation for insurance purposes, consult a certified roofing or waterproofing contractor. These professionals may have non-invasive ways to assess the likelihood of a waterproof membrane based on other visible construction features and knowledge of common building practices in the area.
While it’s often impractical to remove roof materials or walls to verify the membrane, a specialist can offer expert opinions that may help strengthen your case with an insurance company or potential buyer.
3. Keep Detailed Records for Future Retrofits
If you are planning to install a waterproof membrane as part of a home renovation or retrofit, make sure you maintain detailed documentation. This should include:
Permits: Ensure the project is properly permitted and documented with local building authorities.
Contracts and Receipts: Save any contracts, receipts, and material specifications from the contractor who installs the membrane.
Photos of the Installation: Take photos of the construction process, including the installation of the membrane before it is covered by roofing materials or siding. These images can serve as evidence in the future if proof is needed.
Keeping this documentation on hand will provide solid evidence of the waterproof membrane’s existence for insurance companies or when selling the home.
Bottom Line
Proving the presence of a waterproof membrane in your home is a challenge due to its hidden location, lack of widespread documentation, and limitations of standard home inspections. However, with the right approach—such as seeking original construction documents, consulting specialists, and maintaining detailed records of retrofits—homeowners can overcome these obstacles. While difficult, proving the existence of a waterproof membrane can unlock significant benefits, including insurance discounts and increased home value.
In the long run, homeowners in hurricane-prone areas should view a waterproof membrane not just as an insurance benefit but as a critical investment in their property’s durability and protection from water damage. If you’re building or retrofitting your home, take the necessary steps to document the installation thoroughly and ensure that this valuable feature is recognized for the protection it provides.
We’re Here To Help
Feel free to call us if you have questions at 407-319-4608. You may also schedule your inspection or find additional information on our website.